My review of the first season of Vera.
My review of the second season of Vera.
My review of the third season of Vera.
My reviews of the fourth season of Vera.
My reviews of the fifth season of Vera.
Bleak but gorgeous moors? Crows? A crowded pub? A girl running alone in the dark? No depressed Swedish detective in evidence? Must be Vera, and so it is. The girl in particular had just discovered the body of a woman, Anne Marie Richards, left in the wilderness for two weeks.
Marcus the Pathologist, who's looking rather older, hesitantly diagnoses a violent death. She'd been scheduled to have supper with her two daughters several weeks ago. A history of drugs and desertion meant they weren't particularly surprised when she was a no-show. But is that the only reason they refused to seek her out? Could they be responsible for her disappearance?
The daughters are quite different from one another. Christine is gawky and unfashionable - she seems a little more emotionally levelheaded than her sister, but nothing else about her life looks stable. Nicole is married with a young daughter. Her husband, Simon, was angry with Anne Marie - she meddled in other people's lives to an infuriating extent.
As it turns out, Anne Marie was fairly ubiquitous in other people's lives, as evidenced by the parade of suspects Vera interviews. Anne Marie's doctor directs Vera to investigate Anne Marie's latest lover - a restaurant-owner named Huang (a restaurant Aiden visited in the previous season finale, incidentally). Meanwhile, Anne Marie was buzzing around the wealthy older man, Mr. Kipland, in the next house (he's played by Ronald Pickup, here being the suspiciously famous cast member). This worried Mr. Kipland's nurse, Pam Rached, though not as much as Anne Marie's interest in her son, Dash. At the pub, the bartender revealed that Anne Marie had been picking up young men regularly.
Ciara - the girl who discovered and then moved the body - was not entirely moved by righteous motives. Her grandfather hated Anne Marie, because she had caused his animals to be put down. He had been negligent, he admits, but only because he was mourning the death of his daughter.
The superfluity of suspects is somewhat of a problem. There are so many subplots that by the time we get to the killer, there's little time (spoilery stuff here) to develop a motive beyond mere anger (hashtag toxic masculinity), which smacks of convenient, Deus ex machina psychopathy.
This means that the biggest shock of the episode loses some of its weight. For the first time in six seasons, Vera has finally killed off a secondary character.
In the absence of Joe Ashworth, Vera has turned from a show about a partnership to one about an ensemble. Aiden turns up on the advertising, because he's cute, but Vera is just as likely to go investigating with Kenny or Bethany. In this episode, most of her time is spent with Bethany, who has put in an application for promotion. Vera is blunt: she doesn't think she's good enough. Could she be? Yes, but it'll take a lot more work.
That the end of Bethany's first character arc is death, and quickly, is an unusual choice. Sure, it gives the show that darkness it's been missing, but there are a few reasons it's a puzzling decision. For one, we have very little emotion invested in Bethany. I care far more for Kenny, Aiden, and even Marcus, all of whom have had more character development (and I can't even begin to describe how agonizing Joe's death would have been, in similar circs). For another, it's not exactly a logical development of her character arc. It's just a bit random.
All that said, Brenda Blethyn sells it all. Vera's response gives the denouement tremendous pathos, and she mixes ferocity, anguish, and regret to devastating effect. Hopefully Bethany's death will echo throughout the rest of the story, and not merely be an isolated, cheap plot twist. Vera is a show which thrives on Blethyn's dark moods, and if Vera is beginning to regain the edge she abandoned in series 5 (her saucy response to Aiden's engagement gives me hope), that's all to the good.
My review of the next episode: Tuesday's Child.
Want something good to watch? Check out my full list of British detective shows.
Longish
British detective shows demonstrate the absurdity of trying to police without carrying a firearm. Especially when help is so far away on the moors.
ReplyDeleteI think the motive of the killer was quite clear--he was about to lose his live-in victim. His MIL was about to rescue her daughter and get her away from his controlling/abusive influence.
Vera may not break any new ground for a mystery show, but it is still a reliable watch. It will be nice to be able to come here when Sunday's episode ends, too.
I can't even begin to count the number of times I've yelled at the TV: "Take a GUN, you IDIOT!"
DeleteI don't mean that we don't know the motive, it's just that it sort of came out of nowhere. I hadn't gotten any sort of controlling, angry vibe from him before that. Maybe I just missed it - I'll keep an eye out on the rewatch with the family.
Vera's first few seasons were, I thought, quite exceptional (I really loved the dynamic between Vera and Joe) - and though it might have slid into a rut, recently, Brenda Blethyn is always worth watching. This season has been quite good.
there is nothing absurd about preventing the police running round carrying guns, we are very happy about it
Deletemeans most criminals and every normal citizen are not carrying them either
the absurdity is moronic town sheriffs and other badly trained thugs shooting innocent people dead on a routine basis for minor incidents
I'd much rather our police force than yours that's for sure
I bet you wouldn't be saying that, Richard, if you were a police officer. Or couldn't, being dead and all.
DeleteI know plenty of serving policemen in the UK and not one wants to routinely carry a weapon
Deletethey are regularly surveyed and this has been constant for decades
I would never carry a gun myself for any purpose other than clay pigeon shooting or something, so you would lose your bet
you may think guns are the solution but we don't, they are the problem - your ignorance of British society and attitudes and your assumptions are rather offensive
Actually, your assumptions that turn out to be quite wrong, are offensive. I spent time in the UK and have talked with police officers in your country and most would rather go home alive. Perhaps that's why more and more have access to firearms in the trunks of their cars or by having armed response officers present on a routine basis. Your assumptions about American police show a pretty thorough ignorance of the facts, as well. Yeah, we shoot people for dropping their H's and swallowing their vowels. Be careful! You must be Guardian reader. But in the "real" world--at least what this episode portrays of it--the fact of the matter is that DC Bethany Whelan would be alive if she were carrying a firearm. Maybe you could have talked your way out of it with your "purty" mouth, but let's hope you never have to find out.
ReplyDeleteAnother arrgant dumb-ass American who thinks that because he visited the UK once and spoke to a policeman he understands the whole situation here.
DeleteIdiotic gun loving Americans
ReplyDelete#LoveYourPassion
DeleteI'm sorry that some ugly Americans stumbled upon this review and couldn't help but try to make it political. Let me apologize for my ignorant peers.
ReplyDeleteThat being said this was a really disappointing episode. It seemed, as this review noted, the whole thing felt rushed, and your "convenient, Deus ex machina psychopathy" is a superb summary. It was overly-contrived to produce the scenario of Bethany's death. Most obviously - are guns somehow permanently attached to houses? Wouldn't it be quite obvious that the psychopathic character might have it on his person? Shouldn't the supposedly street-smart Vera, who already knew about the gun, have just told Bethany, during her tediously prolonged cell call, to let him go? And not put up a fight which would have been pointless anyhow, since he was a very robust man, who was clearly willing to be violent even without a gun! I enjoy the the better UK crime dramas precisely because they avoid those type of moments of puerile drama and overly dramatized suspense. I don't want to feel like I'm watching the banal gloopiness of "Chicago Fire" or whatnot, where every episode has a secondary character skirting with death. So, for me the series kind of jumped the shark with this one. (remember we on US PBS are just seeing them now) I don't know if I can go on watching anymore.
๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐๐
DeleteWell, they had to get rid of Beth any anyway, since the actress was leaving the UK to play a lawyer in the States on The Good Wife.
ReplyDeleteHello to just look at the problems Guns are causing,Kids dieing,in our school killings,women's being shot on and on But how can we stop guns from coming to our country when we are making them
ReplyDeleteWho wrote this episode? Don't they know it's illegal to own a handgun in mainland UK so there's no way he could've had a firearms licence for one which Bethany fails to check.
ReplyDeleteThat's wild! Somebody didn't do their research.
DeleteI absolutely love this show! ♥️
ReplyDeleteNo idea why they used the Langdale Beck Hotel, a whole county away from Northumberland
ReplyDeleteCan i just say, as someone who watches the show constantly and enjoys it, Bethany's death was a HUGE shock to me- very emotional, and heartbreaking-all the more for the fact we DID NOT see it coming. I certainly thought the show portrayed the heartbreak and tragedy of it all- Brenda Brethlyn did an excellent job of portraying a person who is now suffused with doubt and guilt over the whole episode. What that means for her future relationships, only time will tell. I was in bits because I could not believe anyone would shoot another person in the back -especially when he already had the upper hand.
ReplyDeleteAsa viewer in Australia who loves this show-Friday night is murder mystery night- I thought this was an outstanding episode of Vera. Yes there were a lot of sub plots and twists- your standard red herrings-but that's stock in trade for a quality detective show (i.e. Endeavour). i WAS IN BITS AND TOTAL SHOCK when Bethany was shot- i could not believe that someone who held all the power would shoot someone in the back and not even blink. I admit, VERA'S REACTION AND GENUINE GRIEF HAD ME IN TEARS AS WELL. Brenda Brethlyn never disappoints and her insistance on interviewing the killer over this and the original murder was very high impact. One of the best episodes i have seen in a while and has left me wanting more.
ReplyDeleteLangdon Beck, to be pedantic but yes, I too wondered what the hell the Northumberland and City police were doing in Co. Durham. Still, it's all 'oop north' so what the hell.
ReplyDeleteOnce again, beautiful lanscape, horrible voice by the lead actress, and a boring plot, the “bad” guy being obvious early on.
ReplyDeletePersonally I’m in Australia & love this series from the start ๐คฉ I do find it weird the a police officer doesn’t have something to defend themselves, there are alot of things apart from guns that can defend themselves in self defence!
ReplyDelete& it is quite ignorant to think if Police officers have a gun that in turn our children would have a gun, there are a lot of famers for eg: that have guns over their & there children know exactly where they are and the keys to unlock them! Guns should be illegal for a citizen but not the police! They put there lives on the line everyday for us!!!!
Vera is coming to one of our more popular channels soon! & I really cannot wait 5 stars ๐ from me ๐ค
I just think that this episode shows Brenda‘s best work in the whole series. What a blessing she has been in this role. I am so thankful that it exists and that she is Vera.
ReplyDelete